Another Pleads Guilty in Louisiana Durable Medical Equipment Scam

Yesterday, Rodney Taylor, who was a 45 year old patient recruiter for several healthcare companies in Louisiana, plead guilty to conspiracy to defraud the United States and conspiracy to commit healthcare fraud. He could face up to fifteen years in prison for both charges, as well as a fine.

Taylor was involved in the case reported earlier this week, which involved fraudulently billing Medicare for durable medical equipment, including things like electric wheelchairs and arm braces.

According to plea agreements, Taylor was involved with finding Medicare patient information and getting prescriptions for durable medical equipment, which he then sold to several companies owned by Jones. As part of court records from Jones trials, kickbacks were payed to Medicare recipients, doctors, and patient recruiters to help generate what amounted to over $20 million in fraudulent billings to Medicare.

Taylor allegedly provided prescriptions and patient information to Medical 1 Patient Services LLC , Healthcare 1 LLC, and Lifeline Healthcare Services Inc, which were involved with a Medicare fraud scheme, according to plea agreements, from 2004 until 2009.

Jones, along with her ex-husband and several others, are involved with many different businesses in Louisiana, with ties to Nevada as well. This includes a number of medical companies, several non-profit, religious businesses, and more.

Owner of Durable Medical Equipment Company Pleads Guilty to Medicare Fraud

On Friday, Chikenna D. Jones, the thirty-six year old owner of several Louisiana based durable medical equipment companies, plead guilty to conspiracy to defraud the United States and conspiracy to commit health care fraud.

She faces up to fifteen years in prison for her part in this Medicare Scam, which resulted, according to court records, in around $20 million in fraudulent Medicare Claims.

Jones, as per court records, admitted responsibility for fraudulently billing Medicare for Durable Medical Equipment from 2004 until 2009, allegedly paying patient recruiters kickbacks for providing Medicare patents that could be billed for unneeded medical equipment.

Allegedly, Henry Jones, who was her husband during this period, used information provided by patient recruiters, to bill Medicare for electric wheelchairs, arm and leg braces, and other types of durable medical equipment that require a doctors prescription.

As part of her plea agreement, Jones admitted that she was aware that the durable medical equipment was not required by the patients.

Jones is listed as the owner of a number of health care companies in Louisiana, including Medical 1 Patient Services LLC, Healthcare 1 LLC, Rose Medical Inc., and Lifeline Healthcare Services Inc.

According to public records, Medical 1 Patient Services LLC was founded in 2007 and Healthcare 1 LLC was founded in 2003. Both are related to Aldebaran Management Company, LLC.

Lifeline Healthcare Services was founded in 2004 and the chief operator is Chikenna Jones ex-husband, Henry Jones. The last reported filing for this company was in 2007.

Aldebaran Management Company is based out of Las Vegas Nevada and has a revoked business license, as per Nevada Public Records. It’s registered agent is another company, ACORN CORPORATE SERVICES, which was founded in 1993 and uses the same business address. Rose Medical LLC was listed as the business name of two companies in Nevada, however neither are tied directly to the other companies.

Extensive Business History in Louisiana

According to Louisiana public records, Chikenna D. Jones, Henry L. Jones, and Aldebaran Management Company have ties to a number of very diverse businesses, dating back to at least 2005.

This includes non-profits like Paris In the Spring Education Group and The Lifeline Ministry INC, and , as well as the Non-Profit Religious Corporation, Christian Fellowship Church Ministries, INC.

Other Registered Businesses Include:

  • Mindscape Learning Institute Inc
  • We Shoot First LLC
  • Shoe Laces LLC
  • Cancer Funding Group Inc
  • Homecare Cleaning Services LLC
  • Zoe Equipment Corporation INC
  • Darius’ Freight and Shipping LLC
  • Jairus’ Consulting and Property Management LLC
  • Global Wealth Management Group LLC

Based off the names of the businesses, the numerous business listings indicate that the Jones were involved in many different and diverse industries, including transportation, marketing, film-making, education, cancer research, education, religion, and more. These businesses were, for the most part, registered in Prairieville, Zachary, and Baton Rouge Louisiana.

Owner of Medical Equipment Company Sentenced to 5 Years in Prison for Medicare Fraud

Nnanta Felix Ngari, who is the owner of a medical equipment supply company in Louisiana, was sentenced to five years in prison for his part in a Medicare Fraud Scam yesterday, which was responsible for almost $5 million in Medicare fraud.

Ernest Payne, a patient recruiter for Ngari, was also sentenced to prison, receiving a slightly lower sentence of fifty-five months. Both men will also serve two years of probation and have been fined $2.5 million, although the fine will be split among others involved in the Medicare fraud.

Another man, a doctor named Sofjan Lamid who was paid kickbacks from Ngari, received three years probation, for his part in writing unnecessary prescriptions for medical equipment.

Ngari, and several of his co-defendents were convicted on August 16, 2011 and sentenced on January 12, 2012.

Ngari, is the owner of Unique Medical Solutions, LLC, which provided durable medical equipment for those on Medicare. Durable Medical Equipment includes things like wheelchairs, hospital beds, walkers, and other types of physical medical equipment that is typically covered by Medicare. For most types of home medical equipment, a doctor’s prescription is required to receive coverage and for some items, a more advanced certificate of medical necessity is needed.

Unique Medical Solutions focused on providing electric power wheelchairs to Medicare recipients, however, according to court documents, Ngari began to use his co-defendants, such as Payne, to get prescriptions for power chairs that were not required for medical reasons.

To help find Medicare recipients, Ngari began to hold regular health conferences at local churches and other public areas around Baton Rouge. Visitors to the health conferences that were on Medicare would often receive prescriptions for power chairs, written by doctors like Sofjan Lamid, who received kickbacks for their part in the scam.

According to the prosecuting attorney, this fraud scheme took place from between 2003 and 2009, resulting in over $4.5 million in fraudulent Medicare claims. Unique Medical Solutions received around half of this in payment from Medicare.

Medicare Fraud Report

Medicare, which is Federally Run Insurance/Heath Care System, is one of the most controversial departments of the US Government. It is often ripe with fraud and many in the Health Care Industry feel that Medicare and Medicaid do not pay enough to cover the costs of their service. However, many others, including many of those who are on Medicare, feel that it offers a quality of service that would be unaffordable for many seniors.

Medicare Fraud is actually one of the biggest downsides of Medicare and is something that is constantly occurring. For example, just in the last day, there are about 1000 newspapers articles in the Google News Database that are about Medicare Fraud. Of course, many of these are likely about similar cases, but it serves to illustrate how prevalent this problem is in Medicare.

Medicare Fraud Watch

In Miami, the owner of a Medicare Clinic is facing prison time and will be sentenced today, after submitting $100 million of fraudulent HIV claims and $30 Million in Fraudulent Medicare Claims. This occurred not only in Florida, but also North Carolina, Georgia, South Carolina, and Louisiana. Michel De Jesus Huarte, the owner of the clinic, faces up to 20 years in prison, while six others are also facing prison time.

In California, the owners of a Medical Center that found homeless people and preformed unneeded services on them has been ordered to pay $10 Million. The owners paid people who worked at homeless shelters to act as recruiters, finding homeless people that were on Medicare or Medicaid and paying using them, albeit as employees, in defrauding the government.

In Houston Texas, several individuals who own a durable medical equipment company were just sentenced to repay $36 Million in fines, after they used their position in the home medical equipment industry to bill Medicare for different types of durable medical equipment, like adjustable beds and mobility scooters, which was never actually given to the patient.

Common Types of Medicare Fraud

There are a lot of different types of Medicare Fraud, but more often than not, it is the suppliers of durable medical equipment who are found to be committing these crimes.

Medicare Part B Benefits include the coverage of durable medical equipment, which includes a wide variety of home medical equipment, such as wheelchairs, scooters, and adjustable beds. It also covers glasses, prostheses, and oxygen equipment. In most cases, providing the patient is covered by Medicare and has a prescription for the equipment, Medicare will cover 80% of the cost. There are exceptions to this rule though, such as Medicare Lift Chairs, which are not completely covered. However, for the most part, as long as there is a medical need for the item, Medicare will provide 80% reimbursement for it.

Unfortunately, the home medical equipment industry has always been ripe with fraud, not just with Medicare. This is in part because medical equipment suppliers are not necessarily run by health care professionals or doctors. Instead, they are usually business people who are out to make a profit, which of course leads to abuse. Also, it is much easier to fraudulently sell Medical Equipment than it is to bill for services that are not preformed, so Durable Medical Equipment fraud remains one of the most common types of Medicare Fraud.

Of course, as the examples above illustrate, there are many other types of Medicare Fraud and fraudulent billing is also very common.

The prevalence of this type of dishonest medical billing is one factor that many are using to argue against a state run health care program. However, to be fair, Insurance Fraud occurs all the time in all private insurance as well. However, since most private insurance companies are in the business of denying claims, rather than approving them, Medicare makes an easier target.

Medicare Part B Benefits

Part B Medicare Benefits cover a variety of procedures that are not covered under Part A Benefits. Like other Medicare Benefits, those who are working are able to put off enrolling for Part B Benefits, which are optional, however those who are not working and do not enroll will face a 10% increase in premiums each year.

To Enroll in Medicare, including Part B Benefits, you can visit their site here.

While Part C is used to cover prescription medicine, Part B will cover medication that is given by a doctor. It also covers some doctors visits, x-rays, blood tests, chemotherapy, ambulance transportation, and a number of other outpatient treatments, such as vaccination for the flu.


Durable Medical Equipment

One of the most important parts of Part B Benefits, however, is the coverage of Durable Medical Equipment. Durable Medical Equipment refers to a number of different types of home medical equipment, such as hospital beds and wheelchairs, as well as things like eye glasses, oxygen equipment, and prosthetics.

In most cases, Medicare will cover 80% of the cost of the equipment, with the insured being responsible for the remaining 20%. It is almost always necessary to have a doctors prescription and certain types of equipment will also require a Certificate of Medical Necessity, which is simply a much more detailed prescription that outlines the specific conditions the patient has. Certain equipment will have some extra requirements that the patient must meet, such as someone who wants to have their mobility scooter covered would need to use it all of the time, both at home and away, and not merely when away from home.

While the majority of medical equipment covered under Part B Benefits is covered up to 80%, this is not the case with all types. Lift Chairs, which are basically recliners that act as a standing aid, are one example, as they are only partially covered. They also require a Certificate of Medical Necessity, which among other things, requires that the patient can not stand from any chair in their home. Usually Medicare will be reimbursed for about $300, which covers the cost of the lifting mechanism, but the entire chair is not covered. Getting reimbursement is not always easy either.

Other items, specifically those that involve home modification are not usually covered under Medicare Part B. For example, widening the doorways for a wheelchair user or installing an elevator would not be covered.

Cost of Part B Benefits

A monthly premium is required for those wishing to use Part B Benefits, which is usually around $100. However, since 2007, the premium is also based off of income and whether the insured is married, with a higher income meaning a higher premium and can be as high as $300.

In addition to a monthly premium, the patient must also pay a yearly deductible if they use these benefits, which was around $130 in 2009. There is also a copay required for most items, which is usually 20% of the cost of the item, with Medicare paying the other 80%. However, as stated above, some items, like lift chairs Medicare, are only partially covered under Medicare. However, blood work and other laboratory services are often covered completely. A 15% surcharge is added if the physician is not certified by Medicare.